Discreet packagingFree NZ shipping over $150Hassle-free returnsSecure checkoutAfterpay & Laybuy

Fisting

For those who love the fullest sensation — fisting gear is about going slow, plenty of glide, and staying comfortable every step.

Every piece here is rated by its Coyscore — our category-aware trust score built from thousands of real reviews across the web, weighted for what matters: body-safe silicone, a gradual size range, and shapes designed to build up comfortably. A positioning wedge can make things easier still. Body-safe materials, plain discreet packaging, and free NZ shipping over $60. Jump to the buying guide ›

Shop by type

89

What's a Coyscore? A 0–100, category-aware trust score built from aggregated cross-web reviews — weighted for what matters here. Sourced & updated monthly, never our own star-padding.

Skip to results list
4 items

Filter

  • The Hand — Coy

    The Hand

    The Hand
    Provisional
    4.4 · 113 reviews
    $129.95
    $129.95
  • Latex Unisex Fisting Short — Coy

    Latex Unisex Fisting Short

    Latex Unisex Fisting Short
    Provisional
    1.3 · 12 reviews
    $129.95
    $129.95
  • Belladonnas Magic Hand — Coy

    Belladonnas Magic Hand

    Belladonnas Magic Hand
    4.5 · 263 reviews · 3 sources
    $69.95
    $69.95
  • Hand Of Jamie Lannister — Coy

    Hand Of Jamie Lannister

    Hand Of Jamie Lannister
    $79.95
    $79.95

Good to know

Fisting — your questions, answered

choosingHow do I choose fisting toys?
Start small and build up: choose a graduated set or a toy at the modest end of the range, in soft body-safe silicone with a tapered shape that eases in. A flared base keeps things safe. Plan for plenty of thick, long-lasting lube. The Coyscore weights body-safe materials, comfortable shape and quality from real reviews.
comparisonFisting toys vs large dildos vs training sets — what's the difference?
A graduated training set steps up through sizes so you can build comfort slowly, which is the safest route. Dedicated fisting dildos and hand-shaped toys focus on girth for those already experienced. Very large plugs stretch gradually rather than thrust. Beginners should start with a training set and lots of lube, never the biggest option first.
beginnersIs fisting suitable for beginners?
Yes, with patience — the golden rule is to start small, go slowly, and never rush size. Choose a graduated set, use generous amounts of thick lube, and stop the moment anything feels uncomfortable. Warming up and relaxation matter more than the toy itself. The beginner-friendly tag flags smaller, tapered, body-safe pieces designed for building up.
safetyHow do we do this safely?
Go slow and never force anything — pain is a signal to stop, not push through. Use plenty of thick, long-lasting body-safe lube, trim and file nails, and consider gloves for comfort and hygiene. Warm up gradually, stay relaxed, and keep communicating. Choose toys with a flared base, and stop at once if there's any sharp pain or bleeding.
careHow do I clean and store fisting toys?
Wash body-safe silicone toys with warm water and toy cleaner after every use, and let them air-dry fully before storing. Keep silicone pieces separate from other silicone so surfaces don't react, and store them in a clean pouch away from dust. Pair only with a compatible lube — water-based is safe with all materials.
deliveryIs delivery discreet, and can I return fisting toys?
Always — fisting toys ship in plain, unbranded packaging with a discreet billing descriptor, and NZ shipping is free over $60. For hygiene reasons a used insertable toy can't be returned, but sealed items in resalable condition can, and we'll always make a genuine fault right.

Buying guide

How to choose fisting toys

The right approach to fisting is patient: soft body-safe materials, a size you build up to, and lots of glide. Three things decide the pick: the size range, the shape and material, and safe, slow use.

Coy buying-guide card — “Start small and graduate up”

1. Start small and graduate up

The safest, most enjoyable route is a graduated set or a toy at the gentler end, so you can build comfort over time. Rushing size is the most common mistake reviewers regret — patience does far more than picking the biggest option.

  • Graduated sets let you build up safely
  • Start gentler than you think you need
  • Never rush to the largest size
Coy buying-guide card — “Shape, material and base”

2. Shape, material and base

Soft, body-safe silicone with a smooth taper eases in most comfortably, and a flared base keeps everything safe. Pair every toy with plenty of thick, long-lasting lube — most reviewers agree generous glide matters more than any single feature.

  • Soft, body-safe silicone with a smooth taper
  • A flared base is essential for safety
  • Plan for plenty of thick, long-lasting lube
The Coyscore ring at 83 out of 100 with sub-bars for materials, shape and quality

3. Slow, relaxed and communicative

Go slowly, never force anything, and treat any pain as a signal to stop. Trim nails, consider gloves, warm up gradually, and keep talking to each other. The Coyscore weights body-safe materials, comfortable shape and quality from thousands of real reviews.

  • Never force; pain means stop
  • Trim nails, use gloves, warm up slowly
  • The Coyscore weights materials, shape and quality

Keep exploring

RestraintsRope & TapeNipple PlayElectro SexSex Furniture & MachinesFetish WearFistingBondage Kits

Coyscores and quotes are aggregated from third-party reviews across the web, sourced and attributed — shown for comparison, not presented as Coy's own reviews. Updated monthly.