Discreet packagingFree NZ shipping over $150Hassle-free returnsSecure checkoutAfterpay & Laybuy

Butt Plug Tails

A tail plug turns a comfortable, safe-based plug into playful dress-up — pick your plug size first, the tail second.

Every tail here is rated by its Coyscore, our category-aware trust score built from thousands of real reviews across the web — weighted for a secure flared base, body-safe silicone and a well-attached tail. New to plugs? Start with our classic butt plugs and add a tail later. We stock body-safe materials only and ship NZ-wide in plain, discreet packaging. Jump to the buying guide ›

Shop by type

89

What's a Coyscore? A 0–100, category-aware trust score built from aggregated cross-web reviews — weighted for what matters here. Sourced & updated monthly, never our own star-padding.

Skip to results list
19 items

Filter

  • 5.9 Inch — Coy
    Sale

    5.9 Inch

    5.9 Inch
    $24.95
    $24.95 $49.95
  • Fox Tail Butt Plug — Coy
    Sale

    Fox Tail Butt Plug

    Fox Tail Butt Plug
    $53.95
    $53.95 $57.95
  • 3.9Cm — Coy
    Sale

    3.9Cm

    3.9Cm
    $7.95
    $7.95 $34.95
  • Fundamental Lovers Mask — Coy
    Sale

    Fundamental Lovers Mask

    Fundamental Lovers Mask
    $11.95
    $11.95 $14.95
  • Round Lace Nipple Covers — Coy
    Sale

    Round Lace Nipple Covers

    Round Lace Nipple Covers
    $6.95
    $6.95 $34.95
  • Reversible Lovers Blindfold — Coy
    Sale

    Reversible Lovers Blindfold

    Reversible Lovers Blindfold
    $7.95
    $7.95 $34.95
  • 2.9 Inches — Coy
    Sale

    2.9 Inches

    2.9 Inches
    $48.95
    $48.95 $61.95
  • 2.9 Inches — Coy
    Sale

    2.9 Inches

    2.9 Inches
    $48.95
    $48.95 $61.95
  • Black Butt Plug Tail — Coy
    Sale

    Black Butt Plug Tail

    Black Butt Plug Tail
    $60.95
    $60.95 $69.95
  • Unicorn Tail — Coy
    Sale

    Unicorn Tail

    Unicorn Tail
    5.0 · 8 reviews
    $47.95
    $47.95 $59.95
  • No13 Butt Plug 6 Inch — Coy

    No13 Butt Plug 6 Inch

    No13 Butt Plug 6 Inch
    $39.92
    $39.92
  • Bunny Tail — Coy

    Bunny Tail

    Bunny Tail
    4.3 · 215 reviews · 4 sources
    Silicone
    $52.95
    $52.95
  • No13 Butt Plug 6 Inch — Coy

    No13 Butt Plug 6 Inch

    No13 Butt Plug 6 Inch
    $39.92
    $39.92
  • No15 Butt Plug 6 Inch — Coy

    No15 Butt Plug 6 Inch

    No15 Butt Plug 6 Inch
    Provisional
    4.7 · 10 reviews · 7 sources
    $39.92
    $39.92
  • Dog Tail Butt Plug — Coy

    Dog Tail Butt Plug

    Dog Tail Butt Plug
    4.1 · 198 reviews · 3 sources
    $97.95
    $97.95
  • Bunny Tail — Coy
    Sale

    Bunny Tail

    Bunny Tail
    4.3 · 215 reviews · 4 sources
    Silicone
    $43.95
    $43.95 $53.95
  • Metal Bunny Butt Plug — Coy

    Metal Bunny Butt Plug

    Metal Bunny Butt Plug
    Provisional
    3.3 · 13 reviews · 6 sources
    $39.95
    $39.95
  • No11 Butt Plug 6 Inch — Coy

    No11 Butt Plug 6 Inch

    No11 Butt Plug 6 Inch
    3.7 · 69 reviews · 6 sources
    Silicone
    $37.92
    $37.92
  • Neon Bunny Tail — Coy

    Neon Bunny Tail

    Neon Bunny Tail
    ✦ Coy Approved
    4.6 · 58 reviews · 5 sources
    Silicone
    $34.95
    $34.95

Good to know

Butt Plug Tails — your questions, answered

choosingHow do I choose a butt plug tail?
Choose the plug first, the tail second: a comfortable taper, a secure flared base and a size you can relax into. Then pick a tail style — faux fur for fluffy fox or pony looks, silicone for a sleek finish. The Coyscore weights base safety, material and comfort from real reviews.
comparisonFaux-fur tail vs. silicone tail — which is better?
It comes down to look and cleaning. Faux-fur tails give a soft, dramatic fox or pony effect but can't be submerged, so you spot-clean the fur and wash only the plug. Silicone tails are sleeker, more discreet and fully washable. Both use the same safe, flared-base plug.
safetyAre tail plugs safe to wear?
Yes, as long as the plug has a proper flared base — that's what keeps it safely in place and easy to retrieve. A heavier tail adds a little downward pull, so choose a secure base and a size you're comfortable with. Wear it for shorter sessions while you get used to it.
beginnersAre tail plugs okay for beginners?
They can be — just focus on the plug, not the tail. Pick the smallest plug size with a slim taper, use plenty of thick water-based lube and go slowly. A lightweight tail is easier to start with than a long, heavy one. You can size up once you're comfortable.
careHow do I clean a tail plug?
Clean the plug and the tail separately. Wash the plug with warm water and toy cleaner before and after use, then air-dry. For faux fur, spot-clean gently and never submerge it; silicone tails can be washed fully. Store the tail hanging or laid flat so the fur doesn't crush.
deliveryIs delivery discreet?
Always — every order ships in plain, unbranded packaging with a discreet billing descriptor, so nothing on the parcel or your statement gives it away. We ship NZ-wide with free shipping over $60. For hygiene reasons opened intimate items can't be returned, but we'll always make a faulty item right.

Buying guide

How to choose a butt plug tail

A tail plug is a normal plug with personality attached. Get the plug right first, then have fun with the tail — here's what the Coyscore weighs and what to check.

Coy buying-guide card — “Pick the plug before the tail”

1. Pick the plug before the tail

The plug is the part that matters for comfort and safety, so choose it the way you would any plug: slim taper, secure flared base, a size you can relax into. The tail is the fun part on top — start small and enjoy the look.

  • Start with the smallest plug size and a slim taper
  • A secure flared base matters more than the tail
  • Lighter tails are easier for your first few sessions
Coy buying-guide card — “A secure base does the work”

2. A secure base does the work

A tail adds a gentle downward pull, so the flared base earns its keep here — it holds the plug safely and keeps it easy to retrieve. Check the tail is firmly attached to a base that's clearly wider than the plug's neck.

  • A flared base is the non-negotiable safety feature
  • Make sure the tail is firmly fixed to the base
  • A heavier tail pulls more — choose a secure fit
The Coyscore ring at 84 out of 100 with sub-bars for body-safe, base safety and comfort

3. Fur, silicone and the Coyscore

Faux-fur tails look dramatic but need spot-cleaning; silicone tails are sleeker and fully washable. Whatever you choose, use plenty of thick water-based lube. The Coyscore weights base safety, material and comfort, drawn from thousands of real cross-web reviews rather than our own stars.

  • Faux fur can't be submerged — spot-clean only
  • Silicone tails wash fully and store easily
  • The Coyscore aggregates real cross-web reviews, not our own

Keep exploring

Butt PlugsJewelled Butt PlugsButt Plug TailsAnal Training KitsAnal VibratorsGlass Anal ToysProstate (P-Spot) ToysTunnel Plugs

Coyscores and quotes are aggregated from third-party reviews across the web, sourced and attributed — shown for comparison, not presented as Coy's own reviews. Updated monthly.