Discreet packagingFree NZ shipping over $150Hassle-free returnsSecure checkoutAfterpay & Laybuy

Inflatable Anal Toys

Inflatable anal toys go in small, then expand to fit — insertion stays easy while you control the fullness.

Every toy here is rated by its Coyscore, our category-aware trust score built from thousands of real reviews across the web — weighted for a safe flared base, body-safe material and a reliable pump and valve. Prefer a fixed size? Build up first with an anal training kit. We stock body-safe materials only and ship NZ-wide in plain, discreet packaging. Jump to the buying guide ›

Shop by type

89

What's a Coyscore? A 0–100, category-aware trust score built from aggregated cross-web reviews — weighted for what matters here. Sourced & updated monthly, never our own star-padding.

Skip to results list
11 items

Filter

  • Booty Call Booty Pumper — Coy

    Booty Call Booty Pumper

    Booty Call Booty Pumper
    4.3 · 77 reviews · 6 sources
    body safe silicone
    $79.95
    $79.95
  • Amore Vibrating Plug — Coy

    Amore Vibrating Plug

    Amore Vibrating Plug
    Provisional
    4.3 · 920 reviews · 6 sources
    Silicone
    $89.95
    $89.95
  • Colt Weighted Pumper Plug — Coy

    Colt Weighted Pumper Plug

    Colt Weighted Pumper Plug
    Provisional
    4.1 · 26 reviews · 2 sources
    Silicone
    $92.95
    $92.95
  • Silicone Inflatable Plug — Coy
    Sale

    Silicone Inflatable Plug

    Silicone Inflatable Plug
    Provisional
    3.1 · 31 reviews · 6 sources
    Silicone
    $94.95
    $94.95 $98.95
  • 3 Inch — Coy

    3 Inch

    3 Inch
    $79.95
    $79.95
  • Accordion Inflatable Xl Anal Plug — Coy
    Sale

    Accordion Inflatable Xl Anal Plug

    Accordion Inflatable Xl Anal Plug
    2.3 · 64 reviews · 4 sources
    Silicone
    $130.95
    $130.95 $139.95
  • Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Inflatable Silicone Butt Plug — Coy

    Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Inflatable Silicone Butt Plug

    Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Inflatable Silicone Butt Plug
    Provisional
    3.9 · 17 reviews · 3 sources
    Silicone
    $103.95
    $103.95
  • Colt Hefty Anal Probe — Coy

    Colt Hefty Anal Probe

    Colt Hefty Anal Probe
    Provisional
    2.6 · 29 reviews · 3 sources
    Silicone
    $55.95
    $55.95
  • Colt Xxl Pumper Plug — Coy

    Colt Xxl Pumper Plug

    Colt Xxl Pumper Plug
    4.0 · 189 reviews · 3 sources
    Silicone
    $99.95
    $99.95
  • Expand Xl Inflatable Anal Plug — Coy
    Sale

    Expand Xl Inflatable Anal Plug

    Expand Xl Inflatable Anal Plug
    3.5 · 651 reviews · 3 sources
    Silicone
    $81.95
    $81.95 $89.95
  • Colt Medium Pumper Plug — Coy

    Colt Medium Pumper Plug

    Colt Medium Pumper Plug
    4.4 · 104 reviews · 4 sources
    Silicone
    $81.95
    $81.95

Good to know

Inflatable Anal Toys — your questions, answered

choosingHow do I choose an inflatable anal toy?
Check the deflated size, the maximum inflation and, above all, the valve and pump quality. You want easy insertion when deflated, controlled expansion, and a reliable release valve. A secure flared base is essential. Body-safe silicone is the comfortable choice. The Coyscore weights base safety, build quality and comfort from real reviews.
comparisonInflatable vs. fixed-size plug — what's the difference?
An inflatable plug goes in slim, then expands via a hand pump so you control the fullness; a fixed plug is one set size throughout. Inflatables make insertion easy and let you adjust, but rely on a good valve. Fixed plugs are simpler and more predictable — a better first choice.
safetyHow do I use an inflatable plug safely?
The golden rule: always deflate it fully before removing, never pull it out while inflated. Inflate gradually and stop well before anything feels tight or uncomfortable. Choose a toy with a secure flared base and a dependable release valve, and use plenty of thick water-based lube throughout.
beginnersAre inflatable toys good for beginners?
They're a mixed fit for beginners. The slim, deflated insertion is beginner-friendly, but controlling inflation takes a little experience, so inflate slowly and modestly at first. If you're brand new to anal play, a training kit or small fixed plug is a simpler, more predictable place to start.
careHow do I clean an inflatable anal toy?
Deflate it fully, then wash with warm water and toy cleaner before and after use, paying attention around the valve and seams where residue can hide, and air-dry completely. Follow the maker's guidance on whether the pump can get wet. Store it deflated and anal-only, separate from other toys.
deliveryIs delivery discreet?
Always — every order ships in plain, unbranded packaging with a discreet billing descriptor, so nothing on the parcel or your statement gives it away. We ship NZ-wide with free shipping over $60. For hygiene reasons opened intimate items can't be returned, but we'll always make a faulty item right.

Buying guide

How to choose an inflatable anal toy

Inflatables solve the insertion problem — go in slim, expand to fit — but they live or die by the valve. Here's what the Coyscore weighs and what to check.

Coy buying-guide card — “Deflated size, inflation and the valve”

1. Deflated size, inflation and the valve

The best inflatables insert slim, expand smoothly and, crucially, deflate reliably. Check the deflated width, the maximum size and the quality of the pump and release valve above everything else. Body-safe silicone keeps the expanding surface comfortable against the skin.

  • Easy slim insertion when deflated
  • A reliable pump and release valve are essential
  • Body-safe silicone for a comfortable surface
Coy buying-guide card — “Deflate before you remove”

2. Deflate before you remove

The one rule that matters most: always deflate fully before removing, and never over-inflate. Inflate gradually, stopping well before anything feels tight. A secure flared base keeps the toy easy to retrieve, and a dependable valve keeps you in control the whole time.

  • Always deflate fully before removing
  • Inflate gradually — never force it larger
  • A flared base keeps retrieval easy
The Coyscore ring at 81 out of 100 with sub-bars for body-safe, base safety and build quality

3. Lube, control and the Coyscore

Use plenty of thick water-based lube and inflate in small steps so you stay in control. The Coyscore weights base safety, build quality and comfort, drawn from thousands of real cross-web reviews rather than our own stars, so toys with dependable valves rise to the top.

  • Use plenty of thick water-based lube
  • Inflate in small, controlled steps
  • The Coyscore aggregates real cross-web reviews, not our own

Keep exploring

Butt PlugsAnal Training KitsInflatable Anal ToysHuge Anal ToysTunnel PlugsGlass Anal ToysAnal VibratorsJewelled Butt Plugs

Coyscores and quotes are aggregated from third-party reviews across the web, sourced and attributed — shown for comparison, not presented as Coy's own reviews. Updated monthly.