Butt Plugs
A good butt plug is all about a comfortable taper, a safe flared base, and a size you can actually relax into.
What's a Coyscore? A 0–100, category-aware trust score built from aggregated cross-web reviews — weighted for what matters here. Sourced & updated monthly, never our own star-padding.
-
4.75 Inch -
Booty Call Booty Pumper -
Classic Butt Plug -
Silicone Perfect Plug -
Mood Naughty 1 Medium -
Booty Call Booty Rocker Butt Plug -
Anal Twist -
3.3 Inch -
4 Inch -
4 Inch -
4 Inch -
3.3 Inch -
Shell Shock 85 -
American Bombshell Destroyer Anal Toy 8 -
B-Vibe Snug Plug 3 -
Anal Fantasy Elite Small Weighted Silicone Plug -
Rocker Butt Plug Large -
Buttplug Rubber 7 Inch Model 3 -
Crystal Jellies Anal Delight 5 Inch -
Titanmen The Hitch -
Lovelife By Ohmibod Explore Pleasure Plug -
Penis Butt Plug -
Crystal Jellies Anal Starter Kit -
Pretty Ends Iridescent Butt Plug Small
Good to know
Butt Plugs — your questions, answered
choosingHow do I choose a butt plug?
comparisonButt plug vs. anal beads — which should I get?
beginnersWhat size butt plug should a beginner start with?
safetyDoes a butt plug need a flared base?
careHow do I clean and store a butt plug?
deliveryIs delivery discreet?
Buying guide
How to choose a butt plug
The right plug is comfortable from the first use. Here's what the Coyscore weighs — and what to look for yourself — so you start at the right size.
1. Size and taper — start small
The most common beginner mistake is starting too big. A slim plug with a smooth, gradual taper eases in comfortably and lets you relax. You can always progress to a larger size later — a training set makes stepping up simple.
- Beginners do best around 2.5–3cm at the widest point
- A gradual taper is more comfortable than a sudden bulge
- The beginner-friendly tag flags gentle starter sizes
2. A flared base and body-safe material
Every plug you'll consider here has a flared base or finger loop — the safety feature that keeps it easy to retrieve. Pair that with non-porous, body-safe silicone or glass, which clean up completely and are recommended for internal use.
- A flared base is the one non-negotiable for anal safety
- Non-porous silicone and glass are the body-safe choices
- We stock body-safe materials and flag anything unverified
3. Lube, comfort & the Coyscore
The anus doesn't self-lubricate, so a thick, water-based lube is essential for comfort — reviewers mention it more than anything else. That's why the Coyscore weights comfort, base safety and easy cleaning directly, drawn from thousands of real reviews across the web.
- Use more water-based lube than you'd expect
- Silicone lube degrades silicone toys — choose water-based
- The Coyscore aggregates real cross-web reviews, not our own stars
Coyscores and quotes are aggregated from third-party reviews across the web, sourced and attributed — shown for comparison, not presented as Coy's own reviews. Updated monthly.