Discreet packagingFree NZ shipping over $150Hassle-free returnsSecure checkoutAfterpay & Laybuy

Anal Toys

Comfortable anal play comes down to three things: the right shape, a flared base, and taking it slow.

Every plug and bead below is rated by its Coyscore — our category-aware trust score built from thousands of real reviews across the web, weighted for what matters here: a safe flared base, body-safe silicone, and beginner-friendly sizing. We stock body-safe materials only and ship everything in plain, discreet packaging across New Zealand. Jump to the buying guide ›

Shop by type

89

What's a Coyscore? A 0–100, category-aware trust score built from aggregated cross-web reviews — weighted for what matters here. Sourced & updated monthly, never our own star-padding.

Skip to results list
219 items

Filter

  • Share Satisfaction Small Silicone Butt Plug — Coy
    Sale

    Share Satisfaction Small Silicone Butt Plug

    Share Satisfaction Small Silicone Butt Plug
    $9.95
    $9.95 $28.95
  • Aurora Large — Coy

    Aurora Large

    Aurora Large
    $84.95
    $84.95
  • Milly Anal Probe — Coy

    Milly Anal Probe

    Milly Anal Probe
    $99.95
    $99.95
  • Anal Anchor Ball Ring — Coy
    Sale

    Anal Anchor Ball Ring

    Anal Anchor Ball Ring
    $92.95
    $92.95 $99.95
  • 3.1 Inch — Coy

    3.1 Inch

    3.1 Inch
    $26.95
    $26.95
  • 5.3 Inch — Coy

    5.3 Inch

    5.3 Inch
    $29.95
    $29.95
  • 3.8 Inch — Coy
    Sale

    3.8 Inch

    3.8 Inch
    $30.95
    $30.95 $34.95
  • 2.8 Inch — Coy
    Sale

    2.8 Inch

    2.8 Inch
    $20.95
    $20.95 $24.95
  • 2.6 Inch — Coy

    2.6 Inch

    2.6 Inch
    $32.95
    $32.95
  • 2.9 Inches — Coy
    Sale

    2.9 Inches

    2.9 Inches
    $48.95
    $48.95 $61.95
  • 2.9 Inches — Coy
    Sale

    2.9 Inches

    2.9 Inches
    $48.95
    $48.95 $61.95
  • Black Butt Plug Tail — Coy
    Sale

    Black Butt Plug Tail

    Black Butt Plug Tail
    $60.95
    $60.95 $69.95
  • 4.3 Inch — Coy

    4.3 Inch

    4.3 Inch
    $36.95
    $36.95
  • 4.1 Inch — Coy
    Sale

    4.1 Inch

    4.1 Inch
    $25.95
    $25.95 $34.95
  • 2.7 Inch — Coy
    Sale

    2.7 Inch

    2.7 Inch
    $33.95
    $33.95 $35.95
  • 2.7 Inch — Coy
    Sale

    2.7 Inch

    2.7 Inch
    $24.95
    $24.95 $35.95
  • 4 Inch — Coy

    4 Inch

    4 Inch
    $32.95
    $32.95
  • 2.9 Inch — Coy

    2.9 Inch

    2.9 Inch
    $49.95
    $49.95
  • 3.2 Inch — Coy

    3.2 Inch

    3.2 Inch
    $26.95
    $26.95
  • 3.5 Inch — Coy

    3.5 Inch

    3.5 Inch
    $34.95
    $34.95
  • 2.8 Inch — Coy

    2.8 Inch

    2.8 Inch
    $24.95
    $24.95
  • 2.7 Inch — Coy
    Sale

    2.7 Inch

    2.7 Inch
    $19.95
    $19.95 $59.95
  • 3.7 Inch — Coy

    3.7 Inch

    3.7 Inch
    $28.95
    $28.95
  • 3.7 Inch — Coy

    3.7 Inch

    3.7 Inch
    $28.95
    $28.95
  • 3.2 Inch — Coy

    3.2 Inch

    3.2 Inch
    $26.95
    $26.95
  • 3.7 Inch — Coy
    Sale

    3.7 Inch

    3.7 Inch
    $22.95
    $22.95 $28.95
  • 3.2 Inch — Coy

    3.2 Inch

    3.2 Inch
    $26.95
    $26.95
  • 2.8 Inch — Coy

    2.8 Inch

    2.8 Inch
    $24.95
    $24.95
  • 2.8 Inch — Coy

    2.8 Inch

    2.8 Inch
    $24.95
    $24.95
  • RENEGADE DELUXE CLEANSER — Coy
    Sale

    RENEGADE DELUXE CLEANSER

    RENEGADE DELUXE CLEANSER
    Provisional
    0.0 · 10 reviews
    $58.95
    $58.95 $71.95
  • Aqua — Coy

    Aqua

    Aqua
    ✦ Coy Approved
    4.9 · 210 reviews
    $24.95
    $24.95
  • 7.2 Inch — Coy
    Sale

    7.2 Inch

    7.2 Inch
    $42.95
    $42.95 $69.95

Good to know

Anal Toys — your questions, answered

choosingHow do I choose an anal toy?
Start with three non-negotiables: a flared base so it stays safe to use, body-safe silicone, and a size you're genuinely comfortable with. The Coyscore weights exactly these from real reviews, so it does most of the shortlisting for you — then always pair with plenty of thick, water-based lube.
comparisonButt plug vs. anal beads vs. anal vibrator — what's the difference?
A butt plug stays put for a steady feeling of fullness; anal beads are inserted and removed slowly for a rhythmic sensation; an anal vibrator adds buzz on top. Plugs suit beginners best, beads reward patience, and vibrators bring extra intensity once you're comfortable.
beginnersWhat's the best anal toy for beginners?
A small, tapered silicone plug with a flared base is the ideal starting point. Look for the beginner-friendly tag, which flags slimmer sizes and gentle shapes. Go slowly, use far more water-based lube than you think you need, and never rush the size up.
safetyWhy does an anal toy need a flared base?
A flared base is essential because it stops the toy from slipping in too far to retrieve — the one hard rule of anal play. Only use toys with a clear flared base or retrieval ring, choose non-porous body-safe silicone or glass, and skip anything that could get lost.
careHow do I clean and store anal toys?
Wash with warm water and a dedicated toy cleaner before and after every use, then air-dry fully. Store anal toys separately from your other toys, and keep them anal-only — never move a toy from anal to vaginal use without cleaning it thoroughly first.
deliveryIs delivery discreet?
Always — everything ships in plain, unbranded packaging with a discreet billing descriptor, so nothing on the parcel or your statement hints at what's inside. We ship New Zealand-wide with free shipping over $60. For hygiene reasons opened intimate items can't be returned, but we'll always make a faulty item right.

Buying guide

How to choose an anal toy

Anal play rewards patience and the right gear. Here's what the Coyscore weighs — and what to look for yourself — so your first pick is a comfortable one.

Coy buying-guide card — “A flared base, always”

1. A flared base, always

The single non-negotiable of anal play is a flared base or retrieval ring — it's what keeps a toy safe to use and easy to remove. Anything without one simply isn't designed for anal, no matter how it's marketed.

  • Look for a clear flared base or finger loop
  • Body-safe silicone and glass are the safest picks
  • The Coyscore flags safety and base design for this category
Coy buying-guide card — “Start small and use plenty of lube”

2. Start small and use plenty of lube

The anus doesn't self-lubricate, so lube isn't optional here — a thick, water-based lube makes everything comfortable. Begin with a slim, tapered size and only work up once you're relaxed and ready. Rushing is the number-one regret reviewers mention.

  • Slim, tapered shapes are the beginner-friendly starting point
  • Use more water-based lube than you'd expect
  • Silicone lube degrades silicone toys — pair silicone toys with water-based
The Coyscore ring at 88 out of 100 with sub-bars for body-safe, base safety and comfort

3. Material, cleaning & the Coyscore

Only non-porous, body-safe materials — silicone, glass, or stainless steel — are recommended for internal use, because porous materials can trap bacteria. Reviewers care about this constantly, which is why the Coyscore weights body-safe materials and easy cleaning directly.

  • We stock body-safe materials and flag anything unverified
  • Non-porous means it cleans up completely between uses
  • Keep anal toys anal-only and store them separately

Keep exploring

Butt PlugsAnal BeadsJewelled Butt PlugsAnal Training KitsAnal VibratorsProstate (P-Spot) ToysGlass Anal ToysButt Plug Tails

Coyscores and quotes are aggregated from third-party reviews across the web, sourced and attributed — shown for comparison, not presented as Coy's own reviews. Updated monthly.