Anal Toys
Comfortable anal play comes down to three things: the right shape, a flared base, and taking it slow.
What's a Coyscore? A 0–100, category-aware trust score built from aggregated cross-web reviews — weighted for what matters here. Sourced & updated monthly, never our own star-padding.
-
Rocker Butt Plug Large -
Buttplug Rubber 7 Inch Model 3 -
Crystal Jellies Anal Delight 5 Inch -
Titanmen The Hitch -
Lovelife By Ohmibod Explore Pleasure Plug -
Penis Butt Plug -
Unicorn Tail -
No13 Butt Plug 6 Inch -
Bunny Tail -
No13 Butt Plug 6 Inch -
No15 Butt Plug 6 Inch -
Dog Tail Butt Plug -
Bunny Tail -
Metal Bunny Butt Plug -
No11 Butt Plug 6 Inch -
Neon Bunny Tail -
Pocket Exotics Vibrating Anal T Vibe -
Dr Joel Power Probe Prostate -
Fifty Shades Freed Feel So Alive Rechargeable Vibrating Pleasure Plug -
Colt Waterproof Power Anal-T -
Petite Sensations Pearls -
Petite Sensations Teazer -
White Nights 7 Inch Ribbed Vibe -
High Intensity Vibrating Plug -
Multi Rhythm 5X Mode Vibrating Silicone Dildo -
Paragon Gem Accented Vibrating Anal Plug With Internal Stimulation -
Renegade Pleasure Plug 3 Piece Trainer Kit -
Renegade Sliders Kit Black -
Crystal Jellies Anal Delight Trainer Kit -
Crystal Jellies Anal Starter Kit -
Perfect Plug Kit -
Climax Anal Rapture Training Kit
Good to know
Anal Toys — your questions, answered
choosingHow do I choose an anal toy?
comparisonButt plug vs. anal beads vs. anal vibrator — what's the difference?
beginnersWhat's the best anal toy for beginners?
safetyWhy does an anal toy need a flared base?
careHow do I clean and store anal toys?
deliveryIs delivery discreet?
Buying guide
How to choose an anal toy
Anal play rewards patience and the right gear. Here's what the Coyscore weighs — and what to look for yourself — so your first pick is a comfortable one.
1. A flared base, always
The single non-negotiable of anal play is a flared base or retrieval ring — it's what keeps a toy safe to use and easy to remove. Anything without one simply isn't designed for anal, no matter how it's marketed.
- Look for a clear flared base or finger loop
- Body-safe silicone and glass are the safest picks
- The Coyscore flags safety and base design for this category
2. Start small and use plenty of lube
The anus doesn't self-lubricate, so lube isn't optional here — a thick, water-based lube makes everything comfortable. Begin with a slim, tapered size and only work up once you're relaxed and ready. Rushing is the number-one regret reviewers mention.
- Slim, tapered shapes are the beginner-friendly starting point
- Use more water-based lube than you'd expect
- Silicone lube degrades silicone toys — pair silicone toys with water-based
3. Material, cleaning & the Coyscore
Only non-porous, body-safe materials — silicone, glass, or stainless steel — are recommended for internal use, because porous materials can trap bacteria. Reviewers care about this constantly, which is why the Coyscore weights body-safe materials and easy cleaning directly.
- We stock body-safe materials and flag anything unverified
- Non-porous means it cleans up completely between uses
- Keep anal toys anal-only and store them separately
Coyscores and quotes are aggregated from third-party reviews across the web, sourced and attributed — shown for comparison, not presented as Coy's own reviews. Updated monthly.