Discreet packagingFree NZ shipping over $150Hassle-free returnsSecure checkoutAfterpay & Laybuy

Anal Toys

Shop by type

89

What's a Coyscore? A 0–100, category-aware trust score built from aggregated cross-web reviews — weighted for what matters here. Sourced & updated monthly, never our own star-padding.

Skip to results list
41 items

Filter

  • Icicles Glass Anal Plug No 47 — Coy

    Icicles Glass Anal Plug No 47

    Icicles Glass Anal Plug No 47
    Provisional
    4.5 · 832 reviews
    $39.95
    $39.95
  • Anal Fantasy Collection Vibrating Ass Blaster — Coy
    Sale

    Anal Fantasy Collection Vibrating Ass Blaster

    Anal Fantasy Collection Vibrating Ass Blaster
    ✦ Coy Approved
    4.4 · 48 reviews
    $150.95
    $150.95 $190.95
  • KinKi Zeus Anal Plug — Coy

    KinKi Zeus Anal Plug

    KinKi Zeus Anal Plug
    4.8 · 65 reviews
    $29.95
    $29.95
  • Small — Coy

    Small

    Small
    $79.95
    $79.95
  • Main Squeeze Ultraskyn Stroker Chad White Ass — Coy

    Main Squeeze Ultraskyn Stroker Chad White Ass

    Main Squeeze Ultraskyn Stroker Chad White Ass
    $99.95
    $99.95
  • Medium — Coy
    Sale

    Medium

    Medium
    $53.95
    $53.95 $79.95
  • Anal Anchor Ball Ring — Coy
    Sale

    Anal Anchor Ball Ring

    Anal Anchor Ball Ring
    $92.95
    $92.95 $99.95
  • Intimate Earth Daring Anal Relaxing Serum Foil

    Intimate Earth Daring Anal Relaxing Serum Foil

    Intimate Earth Daring Anal Relaxing Serum Foil
    0.0 · 25 reviews · 1 sources
    $2.95
    $2.95
  • Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Gyrating Ass Thruster — Coy

    Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Gyrating Ass Thruster

    Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Gyrating Ass Thruster
    Provisional
    3.2 · 20 reviews · 1 sources
    $141.95
    $141.95
  • Double Delight Dual Penetration Vibrating Rabbit Cock Ring — Coy

    Double Delight Dual Penetration Vibrating Rabbit Cock Ring

    Double Delight Dual Penetration Vibrating Rabbit Cock Ring
    4.0 · 166 reviews · 1 sources
    $99.95
    $99.95
  • Intimate Earth Adventure Anal Relaxing Serum Foil 3 Ml
    Sale

    Intimate Earth Adventure Anal Relaxing Serum Foil 3 Ml

    Intimate Earth Adventure Anal Relaxing Serum Foil 3 Ml
    ✦ Coy Approved
    4.9 · 156 reviews
    $4.95
    $4.95 $5.95
  • Jelly Finger Stimulators — Coy

    Jelly Finger Stimulators

    Jelly Finger Stimulators
    4.8 · 168 reviews
    $8.95
    $8.95
  • Knocking Rc P-Spot Vibe — Coy
    Sale

    Knocking Rc P-Spot Vibe

    Knocking Rc P-Spot Vibe
    Provisional
    2.9 · 21 reviews
    $59.95
    $59.95 $89.95
  • Anal Eaze 10Ml — Coy
    Sale

    Anal Eaze 10Ml

    Anal Eaze 10Ml
    3.8 · 55 reviews · 1 sources
    $3.95
    $3.95 $7.95
  • Pjur Back Door Glide — Coy
    Sale

    Pjur Back Door Glide

    Pjur Back Door Glide
    Provisional
    4.4 · 5514 reviews · 1 sources
    $38.95
    $38.95 $54.95
  • The Realistic Squirt Cock — Coy

    The Realistic Squirt Cock

    The Realistic Squirt Cock
    4.1 · 1001 reviews · 1 sources
    $89.95
    $89.95
  • Bust It Squirting Realistic Suction Cup Dildo — Coy

    Bust It Squirting Realistic Suction Cup Dildo

    Bust It Squirting Realistic Suction Cup Dildo
    4.3 · 133 reviews · 1 sources
    $99.95
    $99.95
  • Platinum Premium Silicone The Double Dip 2 — Coy

    Platinum Premium Silicone The Double Dip 2

    Platinum Premium Silicone The Double Dip 2
    Provisional
    1.1 · 14 reviews · 1 sources
    $46.95
    $46.95
  • Silicone Double Rider — Coy

    Silicone Double Rider

    Silicone Double Rider
    3.8 · 38 reviews · 1 sources
    $49.95
    $49.95
  • Platinum Premium Silicone The Double Dip — Coy

    Platinum Premium Silicone The Double Dip

    Platinum Premium Silicone The Double Dip
    Provisional
    1.5 · 14 reviews · 1 sources
    $37.95
    $37.95
  • Finger Fuck Glove — Coy

    Finger Fuck Glove

    Finger Fuck Glove
    3.2 · 66 reviews · 4 sources
    $79.95
    $79.95
  • Anal Fantasy Collection Open Wide Tunnel Plug — Coy

    Anal Fantasy Collection Open Wide Tunnel Plug

    Anal Fantasy Collection Open Wide Tunnel Plug
    4.2 · 66 reviews · 5 sources
    Silicone
    $39.95
    $39.95
  • Dr Joel Kaplan 5-Function Prostate Stimulator — Coy

    Dr Joel Kaplan 5-Function Prostate Stimulator

    Dr Joel Kaplan 5-Function Prostate Stimulator
    Provisional
    3.0 · 16 reviews · 2 sources
    ABS Plastic
    $44.95
    $44.95
  • Anal Twist — Coy

    Anal Twist

    Anal Twist
    ✦ Coy Approved
    5.0 · 225 reviews · 4 sources
    Silicone
    $29.95
    $29.95
  • Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Inflatable Silicone Butt Plug — Coy

    Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Inflatable Silicone Butt Plug

    Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Inflatable Silicone Butt Plug
    Provisional
    3.9 · 17 reviews · 3 sources
    Silicone
    $103.95
    $103.95
  • Belladonnas Magic Hand — Coy

    Belladonnas Magic Hand

    Belladonnas Magic Hand
    4.5 · 263 reviews · 3 sources
    $69.95
    $69.95
  • Icicles Glass Butt Plug No 48 — Coy

    Icicles Glass Butt Plug No 48

    Icicles Glass Butt Plug No 48
    Provisional
    5.0 · 96 reviews · 4 sources
    Glass
    $39.95
    $39.95
  • Icicles Glass Anal Plug No 25 — Coy

    Icicles Glass Anal Plug No 25

    Icicles Glass Anal Plug No 25
    4.4 · 240 reviews · 4 sources
    Glass
    $83.95
    $83.95
  • Anal Fantasy Elite Small Weighted Silicone Plug — Coy

    Anal Fantasy Elite Small Weighted Silicone Plug

    Anal Fantasy Elite Small Weighted Silicone Plug
    Provisional
    3.5 · 29 reviews
    $52.95
    $52.95
  • Petite Sensations Pearls — Coy
    Sale

    Petite Sensations Pearls

    Petite Sensations Pearls
    4.4 · 157 reviews · 4 sources
    Silicone
    $48.95
    $48.95 $69.95
  • Silicone Anal Trainer Kit — Coy

    Silicone Anal Trainer Kit

    Silicone Anal Trainer Kit
    Provisional
    4.8 · 22 reviews · 5 sources
    SILICONE
    $69.95
    $69.95
  • Pipedream Extreme Toyz Bubble Butt Fanta Flesh Ass And Vagina — Coy

    Pipedream Extreme Toyz Bubble Butt Fanta Flesh Ass And Vagina

    Pipedream Extreme Toyz Bubble Butt Fanta Flesh Ass And Vagina
    4.3 · 90 reviews
    $995.95
    $995.95

Good to know

Anal Toys — your questions, answered

SafetyIs the packaging really discreet?
Always. Every order ships in plain, unbranded packaging with a discreet billing descriptor — no logos, no product names on the label.
SafetyHow do you check products are body-safe?
We prioritise medical-grade, phthalate-free materials and label body-safe items clearly — look for the body-safe tag on each product.
DeliveryWhat are my delivery & returns options?
Fast, tracked NZ dispatch, free over $60. For hygiene reasons opened intimate items can't be returned, but we'll always make it right if something's faulty.

Keep exploring

Jewelled Butt PlugsButt Plug TailsTunnel PlugsButt PlugsAnal BeadsAnal Training KitsAnal VibratorsProstate (P-Spot) ToysGlass Anal ToysHuge Anal ToysInflatable Anal ToysEnemas & DouchesPeggingAnal Toys

Coyscores and quotes are aggregated from third-party reviews across the web, sourced and attributed — shown for comparison, not presented as Coy's own reviews. Updated monthly.